No One Can See the Gulf: What the Church Asks When Iran and Trump Dispute Seven Tankers

On Thursday, Iran said seven oil tankers had been hit in the Persian Gulf. President Trump said Iran was making the hits up. Within hours, oil touched its highest price since May, the State Department was pulling diplomats’ families out of Saudi Arabia, and reports surfaced of American and Israeli plans to resume strikes on Iran once the American midterm elections are over. Most of the coverage has asked who is winning the war of words. The Church asks a question that comes first: what do governments at war owe the truth, and what may they rightly keep to themselves?

The News Story

Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps said Thursday that seven oil tankers had been struck in the Persian Gulf and near the Strait of Hormuz. If verified, it would be the largest single-day toll on shipping since the U.S.-Israeli war with Iran began on February 28. The IRGC Navy said four vessels caught fire after a simultaneous attack in the north-central Persian Gulf on Wednesday while they were transferring oil from ship to ship, a practice it said was being carried out for an American company on an “illegal route.” It said three other tankers hit naval mines west of the strait and were immobilized.¹

None of the claims has been independently confirmed. Iran did not name the ships, their flags or their owners, and it reported no casualties. The UK Maritime Trade Operations center (UKMTO) reported one incident on Wednesday: a projectile hit a tanker about 11 nautical miles west of Bukha, Oman, the fire was put out, and the crew was reported safe. The Joint Maritime Information Center said on October 18 that an earlier Iranian claim of two supertankers striking mines had “no substantiation,” and U.S. Central Command has rejected previous Iranian mine claims as false.²

President Trump disputed the reports directly. “Iran is doing everything they can to drive up the price of Oil prior to the U.S. Midterm Election,” he wrote on Truth Social on Thursday. “They are even making up fake hits, mines, and everything else.” He said more oil is now moving through Hormuz than before the war. The Wall Street Journal has put flows, including offshore transfers, at about 82 percent of prewar levels, while UKMTO counted 254 transits in the week ending October 14, roughly 70 percent below pre-conflict levels.³

The IRGC warned that if what it called provocations continued, it would extend its attacks to the bases of “the aggressors” in the region. The Pentagon declined to comment, citing operational security.⁴

The New York Times reported the same day that the U.S. and Israeli militaries have drawn up plans to resume joint strikes on Iran. Two Israeli sources told ABC News the strikes would almost certainly come after the November 3 midterm elections, that the decision rests with Trump, and that targets could include petrochemical plants and nuclear sites while excluding power plants. White House principal deputy press secretary Anna Kelly said “the United States will not be attacking Iran at any time prior to the midterm elections” and that the U.S. naval blockade of Iranian ports remains in full effect. Central Command says the blockade, now 100 days old, has kept $25 billion in Iranian crude from reaching market.⁵

The war is also reaching Saudi Arabia. On Wednesday the State Department ordered non-emergency U.S. government employees and their families to leave the kingdom, citing Houthi attacks on airports and infrastructure. Saudi authorities said an attack on King Fahd International Airport in Dammam killed two people and injured eight (an initial count gave one dead). The Saudi energy ministry said two more people were killed when air defenses intercepted a drone aimed at a Saudi Aramco facility at the Shaybah oilfield. The Houthis claimed four attacks inside Saudi Arabia over 48 hours, claims CBS News said it could not verify.⁶

Oil markets moved on the news. Brent crude rose to about $112 a barrel on Thursday, its highest level since mid-May, and U.S. crude rose 2.8 percent to $99.80. Negotiations between Washington and Tehran remain deadlocked.⁷

Catholic Social Teaching Analysis

Seven Tankers Without Names

On Thursday morning, Iran’s Revolutionary Guard announced that seven oil tankers had been hit in the Persian Gulf: four set on fire while transferring oil from ship to ship, three crippled by mines. It named none of them. It gave no flags, no owners, and no casualties.⁸ The one incident an outside agency could confirm that day was a single tanker struck about 11 nautical miles off Bukha, Oman, where the crew put out the fire and walked away safe.⁹ A few hours later, President Trump answered on Truth Social. Iran, he wrote, is “making up fake hits, mines, and everything else” to push up the price of oil before the midterm elections.¹⁰

So which is it? The honest answer is that no one outside a few command rooms knows. The Joint Maritime Information Center found “no substantiation” for an Iranian claim of two supertankers striking mines earlier this month.¹¹ But some of these attacks were real. A Singapore-flagged container ship, the GFS Pride, went to the bottom near Hormuz on October 13, and the International Maritime Organization counts 24 casualties and 120 confirmed incidents at sea since the war began.¹² Neither a blanket claim of seven hits nor a blanket dismissal of them squares with that record.

Meanwhile, a man filling his truck in Kansas pays for whichever story the market believed that morning, and every claim and every denial this week has been aimed, at least partly, at the price of oil. Today, I want to ask a question the coverage keeps stepping around: what does the Church say governments at war owe the truth?

Truth Is a Social Good

The Church places truthfulness inside her social doctrine. The Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church names truth among the four fundamental values of social life and says that “men and women have the specific duty to move always towards the truth, to respect it and bear responsible witness to it.” When a community is founded on truth, “it is ordered and fruitful, and it corresponds to their dignity as persons.”¹³

The Catechism explains why a lie is a public wrong as well as a private one. A lie “affects his ability to know, which is a condition of every judgment and decision.” And then the line that ought to hang in every press office: “Lying is destructive of society; it undermines trust among men and tears apart the fabric of social relationships.”¹⁴ Notice the target. The lie damages the listener’s capacity to judge. A voter, a shipowner, a sailor deciding whether to sign on for the next run through Hormuz: each of them has to decide something, and each needs true information to decide it well.

Pope St. John XXIII carried the principle to the relations between nations. “The first point to be settled,” he wrote in Pacem in Terris, “is that mutual ties between States must be governed by truth.”¹⁵ Under the heading “The Question of Propaganda,” he called for “the utter rejection of ways of disseminating information which violate the principles of truth and justice.”¹⁶ He wrote this in 1963. It reads like a memo for the events of this week.

Keeping a Secret and Telling a Lie

Here, the Church draws a distinction that gives both Tehran and Washington the room they actually need.

St. Thomas Aquinas asked whether it is lawful to lay ambushes in war. His answer divides deception into two kinds. A man may be deceived “through being told something false, or through the breaking of a promise, and this is always unlawful.” Or he may be deceived “because we do not declare our purpose or meaning to him,” and this, Thomas says, is no injustice at all: “much more ought the plan of campaign to be hidden from the enemy.”¹⁷ The Catechism keeps the same line. “No one is bound to reveal the truth to someone who does not have the right to know it,” and the good and safety of others are sufficient reason “for being silent about what ought not be known.”¹⁸

So the Pentagon may decline to comment on operational matters, as it did again this week.¹⁹ The White House is not obliged to publish its target list, and Iran is not obliged to brief the world on its minefields. Silence is lawful. Discretion is lawful.

What is never lawful is the first kind of deception: inventing attacks that did not happen, or dismissing attacks that did, to move a market or a vote. The Catechism names the duty of public authority directly. Civil authorities “should give timely and reliable reports concerning the general good or respond to the well-founded concerns of the people. Nothing can justify recourse to disinformation for manipulating public opinion through the media.”²⁰ Nothing. That word leaves no exception for wartime, and especially none for an election year or a volatile oil market.

Thomas wrote inside the old just war framework, and that framework has moved. Pope Leo XIV, “without prejudice to the right to self-defense in the strictest sense,” now calls the “just war” theory outdated and points instead to “dialogue, diplomacy and forgiveness.”²¹ That raises the stakes on Thomas’s distinction. Diplomacy runs on trust. A government whose public claims the other side has learned to discount has spent the one currency a negotiation needs.

War Fought Through the Headlines

Leo saw this exact pattern coming. In Magnifica Humanitas he warns that “fragmented information environments and algorithms that reward conflict can magnify polarization and resentment, increase propaganda and make shared discernment more difficult. Thus, war is not only fought, but also culturally conditioned through simplistic narratives, a friend-or-foe mentality, disinformation and fear.”²² A little later he describes “hybrid” wars “fought not only on the battleground but also on the economic, financial and cyber fronts, where disinformation and campaigns that feed people’s fears are used to manipulate public opinion.”²³

The price of oil is one of those fronts. Iran’s foreign minister wrote this week that Tehran holds a strong hand over Hormuz shipping.²⁴ A claim of seven burning tankers, unverified, is worth something to a regime that wants that pressure felt in Western gas stations. And a President 11 days from an election has his own reason to want the opposite felt. His own post shows how much the price at the pump is on his mind: he accused Iran of trying to drive it up “prior to the U.S. Midterm Election.”²⁵ I can’t tell you which of these claims is true. That is my point. When both sides treat the facts as ammunition, ordinary people lose what Leo calls “shared discernment,” and with it the condition, as the Catechism puts it, of every judgment and decision.

The Calendar and the Voter

One more piece of this week’s news belongs here. The White House said the United States “will not be attacking Iran at any time prior to the midterm elections,” while two Israeli sources told ABC News that renewed joint strikes would almost certainly come after them.²⁶ The White House did not respond to the reporting on those plans, and I won’t treat an unconfirmed report as settled fact.

But the shape of this situation deserves a Catholic’s attention. Keeping targets from Tehran is lawful concealment, the kind Thomas allows. Timing a decision about war to the date of an election, if that is what is happening, is something else, and it touches the voter directly. The Compendium is plain: “Information is among the principal instruments of democratic participation. Participation without an understanding of the situation of the political community, the facts and the proposed solutions to problems is unthinkable.”²⁷ It asks those in power to treat “the common good, and not prestige or the gaining of personal advantages, as the true goal of their work.”²⁸ Whether to resume a war is the gravest choice a nation makes. The sailors in the strait, the families in Dammam and Tehran, the Americans at bases across the region, and the Americans who will continue to see elevated fuel and food prices will bear it. They deserve to know what they are being asked to support before they cast a ballot.

What I’d Watch

Watch whether the UK Maritime Trade Operations center or any shipowner confirms even one of the seven tankers by name. Watch whether the administration offers evidence for “fake hits,” or quietly drops the phrase. And watch the foreign ministers meeting in Istanbul on Friday, where words will matter more than missiles, if anyone is willing to trust them.²⁹

And, as always, pray. Pray for the crews in the Gulf, named and unnamed, and for their families waiting on a phone call. Pray for the dead at Dammam and Shaybah and for the 8 wounded. Pray for the people of Iran, who live under a blockade and bear this war’s cost at their own tables. And pray for President Trump, for the leaders in Tehran, and for everyone who speaks for them, that they remember who said, “the truth will make you free” (John 8:32), and that they find the courage to say only what is true.

---

This story turns on truth as a social good: a government at war may keep its plans secret, but it may never deceive the people it serves.

One principle from the Church’s social teaching, applied to the week’s news, in your inbox each Saturday.

Get it by email

---

Notes

1. ↑ Francis Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships in Persian Gulf, Warns US Military of Major Escalation,” Daily Caller, October 22, 2026, dailycaller.com; “Iran War Updates: Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes on Ships to Drive Up Oil Prices,” CBS News, live updates, October 22, 2026, cbsnews.com; “Iran Live Updates: IRGC Navy Claims Attacks on 4 Vessels in Persian Gulf,” ABC News, live updates, October 22, 2026, abcnews.com.
2. ↑ Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships”; Mike Schuler, “Iran Claims More Ships Struck Near Hormuz as Trump Accuses Tehran of ‘Faking Hits,’” gCaptain, October 22, 2026, gcaptain.com.
3. ↑ Schuler, “Iran Claims More Ships Struck”; CBS News, “Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes.”
4. ↑ CBS News, “Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes”; Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships.”
5. ↑ ABC News, “IRGC Navy Claims Attacks”; Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships”; CBS News, “Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes.”
6. ↑ “Trump Declares US Has ‘Decimated’ Iran as Tehran Warns It’s ‘Fully Prepared’ for War,” Fox News, live updates, October 21-22, 2026, foxnews.com; CBS News, “Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes”; ABC News, “IRGC Navy Claims Attacks.”
7. ↑ CBS News, “Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes.”
8. ↑ Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships”; Schuler, “Iran Claims More Ships Struck.”
9. ↑ Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships.”
10. ↑ CBS News, “Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes”; Schuler, “Iran Claims More Ships Struck.”
11. ↑ Schuler, “Iran Claims More Ships Struck.”
12. ↑ Schuler, “Iran Claims More Ships Struck”; Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships.”
13. ↑ Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2004), nos. 197-198, vatican.va.
14. ↑ Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd ed. (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 1997), no. 2486, vatican.va.
15. ↑ Pope John XXIII, Encyclical Letter Pacem in Terris: On Establishing Universal Peace in Truth, Justice, Charity, and Liberty (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, April 11, 1963), no. 86, vatican.va.
16. ↑ Pope John XXIII, Pacem in Terris, no. 90.
17. ↑ Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 40, a. 3, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province, in New Advent, newadvent.org.
18. ↑ Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 2489.
19. ↑ ABC News, “IRGC Navy Claims Attacks”; Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships.”
20. ↑ Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 2498.
21. ↑ Pope Leo XIV, Encyclical Letter Magnifica Humanitas: On Safeguarding the Human Person in the Time of Artificial Intelligence (Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, May 15, 2026), no. 192, vatican.va.
22. ↑ Pope Leo XIV, Magnifica Humanitas, no. 192.
23. ↑ Pope Leo XIV, Magnifica Humanitas, no. 204.
24. ↑ Fox News, “Trump Declares US Has ‘Decimated’ Iran.”
25. ↑ Schuler, “Iran Claims More Ships Struck”; CBS News, “Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes.”
26. ↑ ABC News, “IRGC Navy Claims Attacks”; Kapper, “Iran Claims It Hit Multiple Ships.”
27. ↑ Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, Compendium, no. 414.
28. ↑ Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, Compendium, no. 410.
29. ↑ CBS News, “Trump Accuses Iran of Making Up Fake Strikes.”

Books Cited

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

• Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition (Doubleday / Image, 2003)
• St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, Latin-English edition, Complete Set (Aquinas Institute / Emmaus Academic, 2012)